BTSF in chronological order (most recent articles appear first):

Monday, May 28, 2012

Welcoming and Inclusive Worship

Here, we begin a new series exploring how to facilitate disparate cultures' coming together in communal worship for the sake of justice and reconciliation.

How can predominantly white Christian churches and organizations become safer places of worship for people of color? Many Christians truly have a desire to be more inclusive. Yet time and again, a brave POC will come to worship, and then never come back. This scenario plays out in bible studies, fellowship, and churches all over the country. So what is going on?

Several things to consider:

1) Congregational Buy-In. Often, though there are several strong leaders that are wholly committed to making racial reconciliation a priority, it can be hard to get large-scale buy-in from the rest of the members. Inclusively requires a broad-based intentionality that does not waver when life gets busy, or when awkward moments arise. This takes time, commitment and continued education for everyone involved.

2) Leadership reflective of multicultural affirmation. Even if some of the pastoral staff and board members are of different backgrounds, often head pastors and worship leaders continue to be white. We must be attentive to the messages we portray through our leadership. Who is ultimately in charge and who is subordinated? 

3) Affirmation, not appropriation/ homogenization. Across the country there is an emerging effort to incorporate various traditions into the worship service. Unfortunately, the "diversity" songs are sometimes simply appropriated into the established style of the church, without honoring the culture from which they came. It's a good step in the right direction, but ultimately leaves the same homogeneous impression to a new visitor.

4) Intentionality at the front door. Being the newbie is always going to feel awkward, but it is even more challenging when you are very clearly the only person of your race in the room. Churches really do work hard to be welcoming, but the challenge is that for every five new people that get greeted, the one that slips by will never forget it. When those in the majority are more comfortable around folks that are similar to us, it is the racial 'others' that are disproportionately left un-greeted. We must double and re-double our efforts to ensure that this NEVER happens (On the other hand, see Sherie's important warning in the comment section below!!).

5) Stand for justice and reconciliation in the broader community. Sometimes in our efforts to increase the diversity of our own group we lose sight of the greater goal. Too often, a token black member serves to soothe the guilt of homogeneous-ness, letting us feel diverse without the hard work that reconciliation requires. We may welcome someone when they are on our own turf,  but if we do not engage with each other for change and justice in the 'real world,' then our diversity was just for show.

6) Ethnicity-specific ministries and fellowship. Understanding one's own identity in Christ and in the context of one's ethnicity is a central part of the process of spiritual growth (including for those in the majority position). It can also be exhausting to maintain an attitude of worship when you feel you are sticking out from the crowd. When it comes to worshiping God, sometimes it is helpful to remove that burden when we can. Thus, those in the racial majority must never belittle, undermine, or compete against ethnic-specific ministries. But rather, we must support, encourage, and uplift (without forcing our presence, uninvited). Bring to the table the any extra resources and influence that a position of power in a racialized world may provide.

If we let diversity become a chore, a checklist, that attitude will be painfully obvious to the world. We cannot forget that racial justice reconciliation is of the utmost importance to our ministry and to our witness. How powerful it could be to show the world an image Christian unity, rather than a lips service to clich├ęs!

I invite readers to share your personal experiences, frustrations, and suggestions.

See Also:
Why it is Important
Stuff Church People Do
We Bring the Sacrifice of Praise


  1. Insightful point! How ironic to be disturbed by CBC's, and not by the racial plank in one's own eye! least the CBC was upfront with its mission, rather than to imply inclusion, while functioning in exclusivity in practice. 

  2. Joel 1:3 (Whole Chapter) 
    Tell ye your children of it, and let your children tell their children, and their children another generation.
    Effort to incorporate various traditions into the worship service is not what this verse is talking about.  Each race has their own beliefs, and songs that should be sung regardless of place of worship. Different races does not relate to every song they here.   If God is not finish with us, why do we try to put everyone in the same box?  People are INDIVIDUALS not chickens.  Each race feels strange when in the midst of another.  But that's a good thing!  That goes to prove that we are all from Adam and Eve...not monkies!

  3. Praise God?i thank God for all those that doing the market for Our Lord Jesus Christ,the king of Kings and the Lords of Lords.Amen

  4.  Can you write an article about Dave Bailey's new resource?
    Again, Carolyn could put you in touch (he leads worship at Richmond's East End Fellowship)
    enough comments for today!  Thanks for your work on BTSF!

  5. Sherie Made this VERY important point, but for some reason it's not publishing, so I have pasted it below: 

    "Great post as usual Katelin. I definitely agree that it does make a difference to a POC when he or she feels welcomed in a mainly majority environment. However, I would caution against over exuberance in making the POc feel wecome. In other words, dont suffocate them! In my experience, this over attention is almost as bad as being ignored because the poc is still othered by getting special attention. Its like saying "omg we re so glad you re here to save us from the damning image that we re segregated and worse racist!" unfortunately, this response can put the burden of racial reconciliation squarely on the shoulders of the poc because it makes them the savior rather than a sister or brother in Christ. Put simply, show pocs the same love of Christ you would show your white sister or brother, a love that is both purposeful and full of grace."

  6. Ah yes! I've been anticipating it's release. Exciting! 


Creative Commons License
By Their Strange Fruit by Katelin H is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at @BTSFblog