BTSF in chronological order (most recent articles appear first):

Sunday, July 10, 2011

We Bring the Sacrifice of Praise

Follow more conversations about racial justice and Christianity through email or RSS feed.

Please welcome guest author Eileen Howard, Minister of Music at C4AP
She shares some good thoughts for what it means to sacrifice our own comfort in worship 
for the sake of reconciliation and inclusivity:

Across America on Sunday, about 43% of the population will go to worship. In most cases, they will worship with folks who are pretty much like themselves. They will mostly be of the same ethnicity, education level, and economic class. In many cases, members of those churches will say that they really would like folks of other ethnicities to join them. Or they want to reach out to folks who are poor, but poor people “just don’t come to their church”. Or they may even be a church that serves the poor throughout the week with meals, clothing and other actions, but those same poor people do not join them in worship on Sunday.

What these congregations may not realize is that, in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, their church has a big “Keep Out” sign for those who are different from themselves.

For eight years, I have been the Minister of Music for C4AP in Columbus, Ohio. This intentionally cross-class, multi-racial, inclusive congregation has been worshiping with and working with the poor since its inception, and is around 50% African-American and 50% Caucasian, with a few other ethnicities represented.

In order to invite economic and racial diversity, many of us have had to make a sacrifice of the worship and musical styles dearest to our hearts. It required us to shift our worship from being a comforting retreat, to being outreach. It required making diversity a higher priority than our own spiritual (and social) comfort. The exciting news is that, in doing so, we have found a richness of spiritual growth that we have not previously experienced.

Questions of musical style in worship can and do divide congregations in a hurry. The people who like traditional church music, might not like contemporary Christian music, and the folks who like traditional Black church music may not like a “white” style that they consider boring. Some folks find Country gospel music as grating to them as nails on a chalkboard. 

What’s interesting to me about this whole discussion is that most good hearted Christians are authentically interested in church growth and health, and might be willing to make many sacrifices in money or time. But we never CONSCIOUSLY ask people to make a sacrifice in their music and worship style – a “Sacrifice of Praise,” if you will. 

Here are just a few examples of stylistic struggles with diversity and music in worship:
  • Those who grew up in traditional worship may find meaning and comfort in old hymns and formal and liturgical worship. They may be comfortable with pipe organs, robes, and enjoy classical music and choirs. Some people feel betrayed and fearful about “Contemporary” worship. It feels like what is most precious to them is being discarded. They may be turned off by what they see as the emotional and superficial nature of Contemporary Christian worship music. 
  • Many traditional hymns are in styles that were very popular when they were written at the turn of the 20th century or earlier, but they feel old and stilted to unchurched folk. In addition, back in the day, just about everyone learned how to read music and learned to sing in parts; something that can no longer be assumed. Language was different – more flowery, with a greater vocabulary, and now requires a college education to understand. Many people today just don’t connect with traditional worship. 
  • A lot of traditionally African-American music is focused on personal salvation and sustenance, with less of an emphasis on caring for others and deepening discipleship. Some people find it overly emotional and lengthy. Traditionally black services are often filled with vocal feedback to the pastor or choir that may be perceived as disrespectful by others. 
  •  Many churches that do good work for the poor sing songs about social justice and caring for the poor. Many of these songs have a meditative folk/Celtic quality that may not connect much with non-white cultures. Many songs come from the perspective of being ABOUT poor people, not WITH them. Not surprisingly, not many poor folk appear to be worshiping in the congregations that serve them and there is limited racial diversity. 

So, the dilemma is: how can we have relevant worship that is inviting for rich and poor, black and white, young and old, churched, de-churched, and un-churched, that also has depth of discipleship, and includes both evangelism and social justice? Seems like an impossible task!

Worship at C4AP might be described as “blended worship”, but it really goes way beyond that. It is “transformed” worship. We sing old hymns, but we “rehabilitate” them with new rhythms and sometimes update the lyrics to take out the “thee’s and thou’s”. We sing contemporary Christian songs, but we pick those whose message deepens discipleship. We sing both black and white gospel music, but not always the way folks might have heard it growing up. In some ways, we’ve made every piece of music our own, and given it a fresh style that goes beyond just offering “something for everybody.” 

And it’s not perfect. But over time what we found was that folks, for whom traditional black gospel resonated, started liking some of the pop/rock contemporary Christian songs. And folks who liked peaceful Celtic worship music, kind of got jazzed by modern Black Gospel songs. And folks who didn’t think they cared for opera, have been moved and entertained by our own choir director and owner of BTSF, Katelin.

In the midst of learning to love one another and making a sacrifice of the praise that most resonated within ourselves, we have learned to love the forms of praise and worship most cherished by others who are different from us.

Here’s the spiritual gem I have found: Letting go of “my preferred” music or worship style is practice for letting go of prejudices, stereotypes and labels that divide us one from another. It is relinquishing the worship that suits “my needs” and embracing worship that speaks to my neighbor. It is about loving one another through worshiping together.

Follow more conversations about racial justice and Christianity through email or RSS feed.


  1. Eileen, this post comes with such excellent timing, as I am at a Christian music festival, preaching this message and bragging on C4AP to everyone that will listen. The festival coordinator said "You realize that what you are describing happens almost nowhere else on earth." I just beamed. Much love to you all. Be back next Sunday.

  2. Katelin, I didn't know you were the choir director at C4AP! That's awesome!

    As you look for further music to share in worship, Proskuneo, which is based out of Georgia, has a lot of multilingual resources:
    They came to my seminary last year to give a presentation and I was very impressed.

    I'll also say that I resonate with this post... it's hard to let go of the music you know & love! When I worked at a bilingual church where we mostly sang praise choruses in Spanish and English, I thought I was going to scream if we sang "Santo Santo Santo"/"Holy Holy Holy" one more time... contemporary Xian music just doesn't do it for me, no matter what language it's in. But I made sure to listen to CDs of the great (European) choral hymns on my way to and from church, and I survived... And the people with low literacy in the congregation were able to worship through memorizing the simpler lyrics of songs like "Santo Santo Santo."

  3. If you would like to experience a bird's eye view of the services described in this article, The same type of services are held on Tues. and Thurs. mornings at 9:30 a.m., Wed. at 12:30 p.m., and Friday at 2:30 p.m. It is the love of God in our hearts that we can worship together. With God all things are possible. The church is located 946 Parsons Ave. in Columbus, OH. You are always welcome to the circle of fellowhip and praise.

  4. Just saw this, semi-related, very awesome:

  5. OOHHH That is SO COOL! Hope you bring back some good stuff.

    To La Pelegrina, i agree with Katelin... I think offering diverse music that also feeds YOUR soul, as well as being accessible, would be a better choice... I believe it can be done!

  6. A relevant resource that just popped up on my Google Reader:

  7. I have also been thinking a lot about worship within the concepts of melting pots vs salad bowls. We must be careful in worship leading not to appropriate or blend everything to the point of homogeneity.

    Part of the beauty of richly diverse worship, is the contrasts we can enjoy and the interaction with others' heritages. We might miss out on these benefits if we are not careful, so I enjoy groups that try to stay true to the original styles of songs, while incorporating lots of different numbers from various styles.

    I enjoy hearing a traditional organ hymn followed by a gospel song and then a praise song, rather than hearing a hymn in a gospel groove and vice versa. To me, this is more fulfilling and honouring of our diversity than is simply appropriating others' songs into a different style.

  8. 'We bring the sacrifice of praise, by laying our privilege on the alter'

  9. Recent comment from Nikki Lerner on a related forum:
    "Okay, so this is unedited, and just off the top of my head, but... i don't need my church to do all my favorite songs. when I get in my car or have my individual worship at home I can listen to whatever i want! Corporate worship is the story of God and of "us", collectively. Feels like we can turn the form of musical worship into an idol. It's much easier to worship something inanimate like that instead of allowing God to transform us through the tool of music."


Creative Commons License
By Their Strange Fruit by Katelin H is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at @BTSFblog